Winchester Ranger 26
12-gauge steel · 60 min fire rating · Keypad
9.2/10Excellent$1,899.99Nov 13, 2026
9 safes that hold five long guns or more, ranked with steel at 25%, fire rating at 20% and price at 20%.

9 results"Long guns" weightsPrices checked Nov 13, 2026
12-gauge steel · 60 min fire rating · Keypad
9.2/10Excellent$1,899.99Nov 13, 2026
12-gauge steel · 60 min fire rating · Keypad
9.3/10Excellent$1,969Nov 13, 2026
12-gauge steel · 60 min fire rating · Keypad
9.1/10Excellent$2,449Nov 13, 2026
14-gauge steel · 40 min fire rating · Keypad
8.7/10Very good$829Nov 13, 2026
12-gauge steel · 60 min fire rating · Keypad + key
8.3/10Good$1,399Nov 13, 2026
12-gauge steel · 95 min fire rating · 530 lb
8.4/10Good$1,649Nov 13, 2026
14-gauge steel · Fingerprint + keypad + key + phone app · 93 lb
7.8/10Fair$1,699.99Nov 13, 2026
Fingerprint + keypad + key · 115 lb
8.1/10Good$699$799Nov 13, 2026
Best for a large mixed collection that needs depth, a stated RSC listing and a replacement guarantee.
The catch: Returns go through customer service with an approval number, and the policy page prints no window in days, so you don't know your deadline before you buy. It ships within the contiguous United States only. At 594 lb it is the heaviest safe we rank whose weight we could read, and 25 inches of depth will not suit every closet. The 35-gun figure also depends on Winchester's GunStiXX rods.
$1,899.99
At Winchester Safes, checked November 13, 2026
Check price at Winchester SafesRead reviewBest for a family collection of long guns that needs one serious safe for the next twenty years.
The catch: It is 565 lb and needs a 24-inch doorway, so the delivery matters as much as the safe, and Liberty prices it at checkout. The page also names the lock two ways: "Securam Toplit" in the security list and "S&G Spartan" in the lock selector. We quote the selector, since that is what you order. And 60 minutes at 1200°F is a gentler test than the 1400°F Winchester and Rhino quote.
$1,969
At Liberty Safe, checked November 13, 2026
Check price at Liberty SafeRead reviewBest for a large collection that needs room to grow, a stated RSC listing and lights that come on by themselves.
The catch: Sending it back is expensive: Rhino's policy gives 45 days from the ship date, minus a 20% restocking fee and the shipping both ways. On a $2,449 safe that is close to $500 before freight, so measure twice. The page gives no count of locking bolts and no interior dimensions, and "41 long guns" is the brochure figure. Delivery is curbside, about 2 to 4 weeks out.
Best for a first real safe for a dozen long guns, without spending four figures.
The catch: The body is 14-gauge steel, thinner than the 12-gauge that California's regulatory standard asks of a single-walled gun safe (the standard gives other ways to qualify, and Liberty does state DOJ approval), and the page gives no UL Residential Security Container listing. Liberty's fire figure is also printed two ways on the same page: 40 minutes at 1200°F in the product text, 30 minutes in the comparison table. And "24 long guns" is a brochure count: plan on fewer.
Best for buyers who want 12-gauge steel and a 60-minute fire rating for well under $1,500.
The catch: The policy pages on steelwatergunsafes.com answered "Access Denied" when we read the site, so the warranty length, the return window and the shipping terms are blanks in our data, and blanks score low. The page claims no UL listing for the body or the lock. At 18 inches deep outside it is also the shallowest full-size safe here: fine for shotguns, tight for scoped rifles.
Best for owners who rank fire protection first and want a branded 12-gauge safe under $1,700.
The catch: Two blanks. The spec list describes how the lock is protected (triple-steel hard plates, hardened pins) but not which lock is fitted, and Browning's warranty page gave us no readable term. Delivery is also a real line on the bill: $449 to a main floor or garage, $549 with stairs. And the "UL Listed" line does not say Residential Security Container, so we score it one notch below a stated RSC listing.
Best for buyers who want the thickest standard body here, built to order in the USA, and will configure it themselves.
The catch: $2,759 is where the Build & Price tool starts, not what you will pay: size, lock and finish all move the total, and the tool would not open for us on the day we checked. The page states no UL listing and no California DOJ line, so the approvals criterion scores as unstated. The warranty also asks you to pay the freight to the factory if the safe needs repair.
Best for owners who want phone alerts and fast fingerprint access for a few rifles, and accept paying for the electronics.
The catch: For $1,699.99 you get 14-gauge steel and four bolts, where a full-size safe at this price gives you 12-gauge, a fire rating and five times the weight. "Fire Rated: No" is Vaultek's own line. Vaultek ties its alert preferences (email, push, text message) to a ViSN Premium subscription, the backup batteries are not included, and the page states no UL or California DOJ approval. The warranty is 2 years, 3 if you register.
Best for renters and upstairs bedrooms: six long guns behind a fingerprint lock, in a cabinet two people carry.
The catch: SecureIt's page gives no steel gauge, no fire rating and no UL or DOJ statement for the Agile 52, so three of our criteria score as unstated. A light cabinet resists a child and a casual thief; it is not built to resist tools or heat, and you must bolt it down or it can simply be carried off. The electronic lock is covered for 2 years, not for life. The weight is printed two ways: 115 lb in the spec table, 105 lb in the description.
| Safe | ||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Capacity | 35 long guns (claimed) | 30 long guns (claimed) | 41 long guns (claimed) | 24 long guns (claimed) | 20 long guns (claimed) | 23 long guns (claimed) |
| Body steel | 12-gauge steel | 12-gauge steel | 12-gauge steel | 14-gauge steel | 12-gauge steel | 12-gauge steel |
| Fire rating | 60 min at 1,400°F (brand's claim) | 60 min at 1,200°F (brand's claim) | 60 min at 1,400°F (brand's claim) | 40 min at 1,200°F (brand's claim) | 60 min at 1,875°F (brand's claim) | 95 min at 1,200°F (brand's claim) |
| Ways to open | Keypad | Keypad | Keypad | Keypad | Keypad + Key | Not stated |
| Approvals stated | UL RSC + CA DOJ | UL listed + CA DOJ | UL RSC + CA DOJ | CA DOJ | CA DOJ | UL listed |
| Weight | 594 lb | 565 lb | 536 lb | 375 lb | 453 lb | 530 lb |
| Warranty | Lifetime | Lifetime | Lifetime | Lifetime | Not stated | Not stated |
| Sold by | Winchester Safes | Liberty Safe | Rhino | Liberty Safe | Steelwater | Browning |
| Where to buy | Check price at Winchester Safes | Check price at Liberty Safe | Check price at Rhino | Check price at Liberty Safe | Check price at Steelwater | Check price at Browning |
✓ marks the best figure of the row. "Not stated" means the seller's page doesn't publish it. Fire ratings and capacities are the brands' own claims. Each safe keeps its one overall score; this page only changes the order. Prices checked November 13, 2026.
A rifle safe is judged on the things you can't add later: how thick the steel is, how long it resists heat, and whether anyone other than the brand has put a name to it. So this ranking takes the nine safes that hold five long guns or more and orders them with steel at 25%, fire rating at 20% and price at 20%. Claimed capacity is not scored at all, because it is the most optimistic number in the industry.
Here is the rule of thumb. Steelwater is the one brand on this list that prints an average next to its maximum: 12 to 16 real long guns for a claimed 20. Expect about two thirds of any brochure figure, fewer with scopes. On that basis the Winchester Ranger 26 leads: 12-gauge steel, 60 minutes at 1400°F and a stated UL RSC listing for $1,899.99. The Liberty USA 30 is our overall No. 1 and a close second here, and the Rhino Kodiak is the one to buy if you need width. On a budget, the Liberty Centurion 24 starts at $829. Weight is part of the decision: read how much a gun safe weighs before you pick a floor.
Every safe keeps its overall score from the public formula. For this page we re-order the eligible safes with the "Long guns" weights: body steel thickness 25%, price 20%, fire rating claimed by the brand 20%, published approvals 15%, and the rest for the other 2 criteria. The full table is on the methodology page.
Head-to-heads between safes of this list: Liberty USA 30 vs Fort Knox Maverick, Liberty USA 30 vs Browning Sporter 23, Liberty USA 30 vs Winchester Ranger 26, Liberty USA 30 vs Rhino Kodiak KGXR5933, Winchester Ranger 26 vs Browning Sporter 23, Liberty Centurion 24 vs Steelwater Heavy Duty 20.
Other rankings: best gun safe, biometric gun safe, fireproof gun safe, handgun safe, budget gun safe, american made gun safes, gun safe for apartment.
By Grant Holloway, editor, gun safes · updated November 13, 2026